Documentary Blog #40 – Cheat on Food Stamps, get JAIL; Cheat the public, get bailouts!

I know this article is a couple of months old but I wanted to share this with you.  In light of my findings for the documentary and understanding the Food Stamp inner-workings, I thought this was an interesting take on how people are treated for trying to feed their families.  Now I must state that I don’t know ALL the situations surrounding this article, conviction, fraud, etc.  I have to go by what is stated in this article and trust the reporter from Rolling Stone.

I do know that once you have a drug conviction you cannot receive Food Stamps.  However, you can kill, rape, rob or assault someone and still get Food Stamps.  But what I find interesting here is the comparison between a woman defrauding the government to feed her kids and the banks defrauding the American public.  Read the entire article to see how this plays out.  I wonder if this gets you are incensed as I am.

Here’s the article from Rolling Stone -

“Woman Gets Jail for Food-Stamp Fraud;
Wall Street Fraudsters Get Bailouts
By Matt Taibbi, Rolling Stone
November 18, 2011

Had a quick piece of news I wanted to call attention to, in light of the recent developments at Zuccotti Park. For all of those who say the protesters have it wrong, and don’t really have a cause worth causing public unrest over, consider this story, sent to me by a friend on the Hill.

Last week, a federal judge in Mississippi sentenced a mother of two named Anita McLemore to three years in federal prison for lying on a government application in order to obtain food stamps.

Apparently in this country you become ineligible to eat if you have a record of criminal drug offenses. States have the option of opting out of that federal ban, but Mississippi is not one of those states. Since McLemore had four drug convictions in her past, she was ineligible to receive food stamps, so she lied about her past in order to feed her two children.

The total “cost” of her fraud was $4,367. She has paid the money back. But paying the money back was not enough for federal Judge Henry Wingate.

Wingate had the option of sentencing McLemore according to federal guidelines, which would have left her with a term of two months to eight months, followed by probation. Not good enough! Wingate was so outraged by McLemore’s fraud that he decided to serve her up the deluxe vacation, using another federal statute that permitted him to give her up to five years.

He ultimately gave her three years, saying, “The defendant’s criminal record is simply abominable…. She has been the beneficiary of government generosity in state court.”

Compare this court decision to the fraud settlements on Wall Street. Like McLemore, fraud defendants like Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, and Deutsche Bank have “been the beneficiary of government generosity.” Goldman got $12.9 billion just through the AIG bailout. Citigroup got $45 billion, plus hundreds of billions in government guarantees.

All of these companies have been repeatedly dragged into court for fraud, and not one individual defendant has ever been forced to give back anything like a significant portion of his ill-gotten gains. The closest we’ve come is in a fraud case involving Citi, in which a pair of executives, Gary Crittenden and Arthur Tildesley, were fined the token amounts of $100,000 and $80,000, respectively, for lying to shareholders about the extent of Citi’s debt.

Neither man was forced to admit to intentional fraud. Both got to keep their jobs.

Anita McLemore, meanwhile, lied to feed her children, gave back every penny of her “fraud” when she got caught, and is now going to do three years in prison. Explain that, Eric Holder!

Here’s another thing that boggles my mind: You get busted for drugs in this country, and it turns out you can make yourself ineligible to receive food stamps.

But you can be a serial fraud offender like Citigroup, which has repeatedly been dragged into court for the same offenses and has repeatedly ignored court injunctions to abstain from fraud, and this does not make you ineligible to receive $45 billion in bailouts and other forms of federal assistance.

This is the reason why all of these settlements allowing banks to walk away without “admissions of wrongdoing” are particularly insidious. A normal person, once he gets a felony conviction, immediately begins to lose his rights as a citizen.

But white-collar criminals of the type we’ve seen in recent years on Wall Street – both the individuals and the corporate “citizens” – do not suffer these ramifications. They commit crimes without real consequence, allowing them to retain access to the full smorgasbord of subsidies and financial welfare programs that, let’s face it, are the source of most of their profits.

Why, I wonder, does a bank that has committed fraud multiple times get to retain access to the Federal Reserve discount window? Why should Citigroup and Goldman Sachs get to keep their status as Primary Dealers of US government debt? Are there not enough banks without extensive histories of fraud and malfeasance that can be awarded these de facto subsidies?”

Documentary Blog #39 – Happy Birthday, Leftovers!

As some of you have noticed, I have been going back and adding blogs from my several months of travel.  While traveling and then logging and capturing footage I fell behind on my blogs and am having to put them in as close to the time they occurred as possible.  You will notice my last blog was in September but I actually wrote it two days ago and wanted to create a nice timeline of the the story.  Don’t ask me why I did it this way; I thought it made sense but now seems a bit weird considering what I am about to write.

I just wanted to note that exactly ONE YEAR AGO TODAY I agreed to take on the daunting task of making this documentary.  It was on January the 5th that I told the executive producers I would take on this documentary and bring to light the issue of senior hunger.  Initially this was supposed to be a 20 minute film and I was to shoot it in LA and San Francisco only.  However, this film has grown, new information was discovered (along with some great and colorful people) and the money allowed us to find the story instead of just trying to tell a story.

I will admit that the last year has been a difficult one for me considering I set most of my business aside to make this project but have been slowly growing my photography business during our breaks, I secured studio space and had several shoots with lots of wonderful new clients.  I am just ready for this film to be released so we can all see what has transpired over the last year and bring this issue to the American public.  Also, I believe all of us involved are ready for this project to conclude so we can all move forward with it and let it be seen.

But I don’t complain about things like the amount of time this has taken or the pressure and challenges I have faced.  Instead, I reflect on all I have learned and seen, the people I have met and the stories they have told.  Their stories need to be seen and heard and I can’t wait for that to happen.  Tremendous organizations deserve tremendous recognition for their selfless and passionate works.

But until this film is completed I can at least say, “Happy Birthday, Leftovers!”

Documentary Blog #38 – Recap of the D.C. Trip & Organizations

My four days in Washington, D.C. have come to an end and I am walking away (well, actually flying away) from here with so much great information.  First off, the people at Meals on Wheels Association of America (MOWAA) and the National Council on Aging (NCOA) are some of the best people I have met who are working their asses off to make certain someone is looking out for the seniors of America.    Secondly, if it weren’t for these organizations I often wonder what would be happening to current and future seniors and who would be fighting for them.  Keep in mind, people working for the not-for-profits are often some of the hardest working people in the country because their work is a passion… it’s personal.

Enid sharing her passion during our interview

I should explain what these organizations are all about and how important it is for this documentary to have two amazing organizations such as these.  Actually, I am flattered to have MOWAA, NCOA and AARP as part of this piece.  Without these groups I don’t know where this documentary would have become.  It not only adds credibility but it allows people who are this passionate to talk about what it is they are doing, the progress they are making and the future prognosis of the “Senior Hunger” (as well as other senior) issues.

Jim Firman of NCOA during our interview

The reason I chose MOWAA to be a part of this film is fairly obvious.  We’re doing a piece on senior hunger and the two largest organizations feeding people in the U.S. are Meals on Wheels and Feeding America.  As I already stated in a previous post, you know Feeding America (the national organization and not the local level) never called me back or wanted to be a part of this movie.  Meals on Wheels is an old, old organization serving millions of meals every year to seniors and other people who require the basic necessity of food.  I wanted them to be a part of this film long before they ever gave money to my project.  While interviewing Enid from MOWAA I learned some amazing things about her organization, what’s happening in America and how they battle every day with Congress to get more and more assistance to help people in this country.  My question is… why is it a battle?  That’s another film for another filmmaker.

Please look up this "One Away" program from the NCOA

With regard to NCOA, I can’t express enough how great it was to have them on board too.  Jim Firman was great and amenable to helping me get out the story and share how they are a part of the lives of many seniors.  In case you aren’t familiar with NCOA then you definitely need to look them up.  Basically, they are a group that strives to improve the lives of older adults, especially those who are vulnerable and disadvantaged.  In fact, you have to check out one of their great programs that inspired me to want to interview them and have them be a part of this film.  That program is called “One Away” and it’s a series of stories of people who are/were one paycheck, health issue, emergency or other issue away from finding themselves in major crisis.  It’s really worth checking out and seeing what’s happening.

I think that many people don’t realize how real hunger is in the U.S. and this campaign brings it to life.  Also, my relationship with NCOA opened the door for my personal redemption in this film but that’s a later post for a later date.  Heck, I may never even mention it because I don’t want to give away too much about this film.  All in all, my trip to D.C. was well worth the time and money to get some much needed credibility to my film and I am so thankful for their time and commitment to helping me tell this story.

Check out their websites on my LINKS page.

Documentary Blog #37 – Wandering around DC

I will be short in this post but I want to bring up some points or thoughts I had while walking around DC.  This was my second time in DC and the first time I had some time on my hands to walk around, take in the sights and see the splendor of our nation’s capitol.  My first time in DC I was working almost every minute of the day and only had time to eat, sleep and work.  I did take in an art museum but that was all I had time for while in DC nearly 12 years earlier.

On this trip I had set aside some time for Kaleb and me to walk around DC, get B-Roll of all the monuments and people.  We rode the tour busses, walked around the monuments, took photos and interviewed people on the streets.  While walking around the Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, FDR and other monuments and memorials I started wondering what the people who founded this country would think about the state of our union.  Essentially we have become a country that is better served by the interests of corporations than the people.  We have corporations running and making everything in this country.  The family farm no longer exists, our food is processed in massive plants, hell, we all drink water made and bottled by corporations!

I really do wonder what Jefferson would say about America today?

Don’t get me wrong, I think capitalism is great and I believe competition brings out the best in everyone (and sometimes the worst) and still believe in a country where hard work, innovation and determination leads to great things.  I am a big fan of the “individual” in this country and I think our founding fathers had those same beliefs.  But they also though about a country that took care of its people.  After all, we are supposed to have a government that is “of the people, by the people and for the people.”  I think Abraham Lincoln was right in his Gettysburg address when he made the previous statement but something has changed and somewhere along the lines we have lost that perspective.  Hopefully this film can open some eyes and help remind people that we live in a great country that allows us great freedoms.  Perhaps our government can get back to thinking about its people rather than the corporations.  After all, it’s the people of this country – the workers, teachers, artists, entrepreneurs, laborers, farmers, volunteers and the civic-minded – who make America truly the great country that it has become.

As long as this monumnet exists, I will always have hope for America.

The Washington Monument at midday.

Documentary Blog #36 – Are you part of the problem?

One day one of my time in Washington, DC I had scheduled time with the incomparable Enid Borden.  She is the president of Meals on Wheels Association of America and one of the most passionate people I have met.  She graciously allowed us to have a couple hours of her time to interview her and we took every minute of that time and then some.  Let me describe Enid as detailed and as affectionately as possible…

When I first met Enid I was surprised by how small and petite this woman is.  Then again, I am 6’ 3” so a lot of people are small and petite to me.  But she is about 5’ 3” tall and weighs about 110 lbs. wet.  But don’t let her petite size fool you.  This woman has a huge heart and an even bigger presence.  It’s almost intimidating.  Although I am not intimidated by many people, she was a little scary when first meeting her but once you get her talking you realize her fierceness comes from her passion to do the right thing and make a difference in this world for seniors or anyone going hungry.

Enid Borden of Meals on Wheels Association of America

We talked for about three hours and got some really great information regarding what is going on with Meals on Wheels, the challenges she faces and the hope for the future.  My biggest fear in interviewing someone like Enid (or anyone working for an organization) is that she wouldn’t speak openly.  Many times people in power positions like Enid tend to talk in “corporate speak” where all of their answers are taken from a press release or something that is said in their many, many brochures.  In a film like this I have to get people to open up, speak honestly and tell the real story about what’s happening in America.  There were a couple of times it appeared as if Enid was using “corporate speak” with some lines here and there but once we were about 15 minutes into the conversation all “corporate speak” seemed to disappear and we were rolling.

During that conversation there were many points made that had me thinking but there were two points that are still resonating with me.  One is in regard to aging in America and how we all live in a world of denial and don’t want to think about getting old.  She told me that may people are afraid to think about getting old or helping seniors so much so that they won’t go and knock on their doors.  Many people are afraid of what’s on the other side of that door because what they’ll see is their future.  When she made that point it resonated so deeply with me because that speaks volumes to my attitude toward seniors.  Perhaps that’s why I never thought about or wanted to get involved with seniors because of the fear of what’s on the other side of the door.

The second point she talked that still has me thinking is in regard to being part of the solution and helping to create a future where something like this (senior hunger) no longer exists.  We all have the choice to either be a part of the problem or be a part of the solution.  But since I have been thinking about that statement from Enid I have been pondering what to do about the solution.  And, it was this point from her that prompted me to wonder about a solution to senior hunger and how we can make a difference in this country.

Also while in DC we met with Jim Firman the president of the National Council on Aging.  During his interview he used a lot of corporate speak and we only had 45 minutes with him but his last 15 minutes we just as passionate as anything I heard from Enid.  Some people are more comfortable on camera than others and it takes some time to warm up before they open up and speak their minds instead of talking like some buttoned-up, shiny-haired Public Relations clone who speaks like someone pulled a drawstring from the back of his or her neck.

The one thing Jim said that has also stayed with me was in regard to fixing the senior hunger problem in 2-3 years.  However, like Enid, there were no real solutions provided.  To their defense, I don’t know if a solution could have been reached in the short amount of time we spent together.  But what those conversations did for me was to provide further interest in trying to understand, seek or possibly find a solution.  And, that fueled me to want to learn more and see what else I can bring to the overall production of this film.